All the scriptures of the world glorify sacrifice. What is
It is giving up something that you ..
Good, bad, confusing - Hinduism, under the lens Part 02
Continued from Good, bad, confusing - Hinduism, under
the lens Part 01 | Due to the fact that the Kurukshetra war
took place several thousands of years ago, time itself corrupts the
story. Kings and princes who claimed to be direct descendants of a
wise and enlightened individual named Krishna probably must have
corrupted the Gita in order to project their ancestor as God
strictly for political gain. Dr. Narhari Achar of the Department of
Physics at the University of Memphis had done dating of the
Mahabharat war using astronomy. With the help of the Planetarium
software he proved that Kurukshetra war took place around 3102 BCE
(before Common Era). Obviously, there is no way to prove the
divinities took place but the timeline suggests that there has been
plenty of time (and foreign invasions) for the surrounding events
of the Mahabharat to have been altered and changed. Although,
carbon dating, archaeological finds, temples etc. all pile the
evidences suggesting that the red-line story of Mahabharata took
While the concept of God in Sanatan Dharma is extremely broad and open to interpretation, we as Dharmic people have for that reason been very liberal in naming people (and animals) God. Unlike the Christians and Muslims, who from very young age are instilled with fear of their monotheistic and jealous God of which can be read about in the first three commandments for the Christians and the sin of ‘shirk’ in Islam, which is the sin of idolatry and polytheism. Shirk, according to many Islamic scholars, ranks as the ‘mother of all sins’. In Dharmic culture, in the past and present, we have not been fearful of some patriarchal monarch in the sky waiting for us to die so that He can either place us in a paradise filled with materialistic desires or, if we have behaved away from the dogmas of religion, to hell, where a former aide of his, Lucifer or the Devil/Shaytaan, will burn us for all eternity.
If this ‘Christ-Islamic’ concept of heaven and hell were to be true, most of us who adhere to the Dharmic paths, would be the first ones in hell because in our liberal, cheerful and festive societies we have built temples for the ‘God of Cricket’, Sachin Tendulkar and the ‘God of the Offside’, Saurav Ganguly – something which we should ponder over in relation to Krishna, Ram etc. Whenever someone in our societies has contributed something positively and brought added wisdom to it, we have named them as Gods on Earth, or ‘avatars’, which translates to ‘coming down’ – is this right or wrong? Does it really matter? Who knows whether God is a man and not a woman or even genderless? Who knows whether God isn’t a large snake or a flying monkey? Sanatan Dharma has been very wise in this respect: we have broadened our horizons and opened up to the possibility that God, whatever the concept may be, can express itself in any form. This is perhaps why our societies, in ancient times at least, have never fought for such petty things such as religion unlike the followers of Christianity and Islam – whose terror, crusades, jihad, slavery, colonization etc. have all been done in the name of this one God.
If only the message of Vedic wisdom would have reached them earlier we could have avoided the wars on our motherland between the brutal and barbaric Islamic forces in where the latter saw us as mere polytheists and thereby fit for slaughter, slavery, conversions, genocide and rape. Moreover, they probably justified the destructions of our temples, libraries, and universities as a God given sanction. Yet, who is to say Egyptian or Roman polytheism is wrong? Who is to say atheism is wrong? Nevertheless, Sanatan Dharma has never fought wars to suppress, enslave or propagate its values with brute force on humanity:
Rigveda Mandala 1 Sukta 164.46 : “They call it Indra, Mitra, Varuna, Agni as well as Garutman of heavenly plumage. That which exists is One, sages call it by various names.”
Rigveda Mandala 8 Sukta 58.2 : “One fire burns in many ways; one Sun illumines the world; one dawn dispels the darkness of night; all that exists is One and it has taken all these various forms.”
The last subject which I want to clarify about is the notorious “caste-system”. Let me make clear to you that the “caste-system” is one of the filthiest issues that have stained not only Sanatan Dharma but also our national politics. Politicians are not afraid to use it for their advantage. However, saying so, a world without division of labour is impossible and if you want a non-Indian and non-Dharmic source backing this claim, please read Plato’s ‘Republic’ and the chapter named ‘The Guardians’ Life and Duties’. Though, the problem arises when man yields his influence in society and makes a position a birth-given right rather than something achieved through merit. To a certain degree, one may call this nepotism and India is plagued with this menace – all the way from Bollywood to national politics (Nehru/Gandhi; Yadavs; Pawars etc.).
Related Articles - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Sanatan Secularism Part 01
Current Indian History and Conclusion : Dr. Swmay
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
The idea of a social order (or division of labour) was first presented in one of our most sacred texts: the Vedas. The Vedas also happens to be mankind’s oldest literature and drew an analogy of the human body in relation to the division of labour: Head, which symbolized thinking and knowledge would consist of the ‘Brahmins’; the chest which symbolized valour would consist of the Kshatriyas whose role in society would be to rule and protect the citizens; the hands which symbolized labour would consist of the Vaishyas which would consist of merchants, agriculturists or in other words the wealth of society; finally we have the legs symbolizing the part that upholds the body (society) would consist of the ‘Shudras’ which would consist of labourers, craftsmen etc. Society would obviously face a disadvantage if one part of the body was to be neglected.
Even Sri Krishna backs the claim that one’s position in society should be determined by personal qualities and not by birth:
Bhagvad Gita: chapter 18, verse 41 : "The duties of the Brahmins, the Ksatriyas and the Vaishyas as well as of the Shudras have been assigned according to their inborn qualities, Arjun."
I would therefore hope that we as followers of Sanatan Dharma will understand how to value, preserve and most importantly learn from the vibrant and rich mythology we have. Moreover, we must also fight the menace of birth-based caste in our society. Therefore, instead of falling prey to blind faith, let us read, understand and value our rich heritage.
Author : Arjun aka Salkia | Follow the writer on twitter.com/asethi87
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Disclaimer: The author is a commentator on issues of national interest. These are his personal views and do not necessarily reflect IBTL's opinion.
Share Your View via Facebook
All the scriptures of the world glorify sacrifice. What is sacrifice?
CAG has said that 90% of the India's pending income tax (I-T) payments are owed by just 12 individuals. The list is topped..
Being true to his reputation of the Lion of Indian politics, Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi has now done what Indian..
Ecological Agriculture Movement’s Women Group gets huge success in marketing of traditional foods. Ladoos of Jowar, ..
India’s oldest city & one of the oldest continuously inhabited cities of the world, Varanasi will be the cente..